Niall Ferguson, the husband of Ajaan Hirsi Ali, the Dutch fighter against
islam from Somalia, had this week an interview in Barron’s (Is America
Becoming an Anti-Risk Welfare State?). This excellent right wing economic historian was
interviewed because of his book Civilization, The West and the Rest.
He is afraid that the US will go down like the Netherlands
in the 18th century (the spirit of Jan Salie, who didn’t take any risk after
the 17st century in which the Netherlands became the richest nation in the
world) or like Brittan after 1913.
He sees two reasons for the coming decay of the US:
1. 1. The institutions no longer work as efficient
as in the past. The judicial system is a buren. Litigation is everywhere at a
high cost for companies. It has become too complicated (Dodd Frank legislation
of 2000 pages etc.) . You create an army of lawyers.
2.2. The culture
in the US is shifting in the direction of no more risk taking. In the past risk
taking was in high respect, nowadays it is moral hazard and welfare state
thinking is winning. Entrepreneurial spirits are now higher in Hong Kong and Germany
than in the US.
The old
powers will be replaced by the new. That is what happened with the UK in the
20st centrury. It became less flexible and the vested interests became a burden
(labour unions asking too much, inflexible etc.).
The
tremendous growth in the West of the past two centuries was caused by six
killer applications according to Ferguson. The rest of the world could not
follow. These six
are: competition, science, judicial system, modern medicine, consumerism [
thanks to the unions that Ferguson so despises!] and work ethics.
This is
reasonably in line how Ter Veer and I explain in our book why the Industrial
Revolution started in Brittan: because of the big flexibility, the powers in
the society could shift (becoming stronger and weaker according to the spirit
of the age). That compares with competition and the success of consumerism.
This works when the domains of the spirit of the age (freedom, justice, care)
are well managed. You must have up to
date institutions, a good judicial system, a social welfare system. Then
freedom is possible and will work with bigger innovative powers (science of
Ferguson) and profits of the invisible hand.
Now sees Ferguson
a power shift to China at the cost of the West. The trends of the end of the 20st/
start 21st century will continue, that more and more countries will
get richer and close in on the West for income.
Latin
America remains on the right path under the lead of Brazil. Institutions will improve
further.
Europe will
remain a disaster zone. They will keep the euro at a GDP cost of 5-8% per annum.
China is comparable with South Corea in the 70s. Like Korea it will get much
richer and not collapse. They will keep a form of state capitalism. It is too
dangerous for China to allow a powerful opposition in the coming decades. This
system can and will work.